I have nothing to compare the P4 as I have come off of motorcycles. It handles the Florida sugar sand very well, doesn't like the Florida swamp mud, where skinny ATV tires have gone through. LOL We use ours on a daily basics, picking and taking kids to the bus stop, stuff around the house to taking the kids to their horse riding lesson. I am very pleased with the P4 and it appears it will be around in the family for a while.