I did option 2 today and it hasn't gone very smoothly.
Wasn't any problem to take everything apart other than the tie rod on one side; I need to refill with some grease as the tool pushed a lot of it out of the boot.
Getting things back together was an issue - it's still not together. The replacement OEM arms had ball joints installed in them (and only like 400 miles on them) and they looked relatively clean. However, as I was trying to put the right side upper arm on - the new one - I could not get the castle nut on. Upon closer inspection, the threads on the ball joint were badly out of alignment - I think the previous owner may have pounded on it with a hammer to remove it, or it fell with a lot of force on something. I tried to grind down the first couple threads on it but it just wasn't going to work as the deformation was the first 4-5 threads. I contemplated cutting that portion off, but then the hole for the cotter pin would have been cut. So, I was forced to try to extract the ball joint from the control arm without the proper tool - I have the tools to pop ball joints out of the hub, but not out of a control arm. I tried to jury-rig one using a c-clamp. That didn't work (oh, and yes, I did remove the snap ring first). My local auto parts store didn't have the right tool to borrow, nor buy, so I have to order one from Amazon.
I also need to buy some larger snap ring pliers - the snap-rings on the bottom arms are bigger than the top ones and my snap ring pliers don't quite open far enough to work on those. Hopefully I can pop the ball joint out of the control arm easily with the tool on Monday so I can get this thing put back together.
As I have it jacked up, I noticed all kinds of dings and dents in the bottom tube rock sliders and a big dent in the front skid plate on the bottom. It has a metal skid plate on the bottom that replaced the OEM plastic one and most of the dings are on the sides where the plate doesn't cover on the tubes, which I don't think is part of the actual frame. I assume these are just to be expected and not a concern unless it bends the frame, cracks it or puts a hole in it...
Here's a pic of the front skid plate/bumper hit on the bottom front. I assume this is really just cosmetic as well?
View attachment 286712