I thank everybody for their input on insurance. Even after loosing a machine I am still on the fence. My machine was 3 years old, it is my belief that some depreciation formula would maybe pay out 50% if I jumped thru all the hoops they set before me.....I don't mind paying premiums, but I don't need a useless policy that leaves me feeling ripped off if I file a claim. If I could pay 1$ per day for true replacement value as suggested, that would be reasonable.
My 2014 Grizzly 700 is insured. It has some coin tied up in accessories (about 1/3 of what I paid for the machine new), which are covered in addition to the vehicle's value.
Some insurance companies offer ACV (actual cash value) or total loss coverage. The former would be the market rate/age/condition depreciated value while, if you can find the latter, they reimburse you the cost of what a *current* model year of the same machine costs. On the total loss coverage, some limit that to just the first few years of ownership, then change it to ACV only.
Keep in mind that the value of ORVs have been staying up there in value. While I can't right say what every one sells for, I see a ton of Grizzly's that are as old or older than mine, but are listed for sale for near or, in some cases, MORE than what I paid for mine.
Everyone has to make their own decisions. I would agree that, at some point (age, condition, cost of new, etc.), it might not be worth paying an insurance premium for collision or comprehensive coverage.