That is what I tell people a snorkel with a filter on it is the cheapest option. But, it is one more filter to deal with, if it rains or the filter packs with dust how much is air flow restricted? How much restriction is there by adding a filter? It may not make a difference, but I don't know that anyone has Dyno tested it. I do know that the KWT has been dyno tested and I don't have to mess with it. So for me it's worth it.
Choices.
Being new to SxSs, I'd never heard of a particle separator even though I've followed racing most of my life. I was in sticker shock outfitting my Talon and the cost of them didn't sit well with me
(I'm over that).
As I've mentioned (maybe too often ☺), I'm retiring from a 50 year career of dirt bikes, aging out - how'd THAT happen?
That's to say I'm very familiar with the efficiency of oiled foam air filters, they're very dang good. The first snorkel I saw was the SYA but it replaced the goofy intake chamber Honda uses - which is either for intake tuning or noise control and I didn't want to remove it.
It was about this time I saw HondaBob's snorkel idea, it keeps the intake chamber and uses a Uni pod foam filter as a prefilter. Uni has name recognition for me, they've been around for decades. Bob also provided all the photos, part numbers and sources necessary to copy his Talon snorkel idea - game on.
Not to hijack your thread, just a photo to show others another choice. Bob runs his filters just under the roof which I may do in the future, primarily for rain riding (which I prefer NOT to do but ...). I've already spent hours in a steady drizzle and didn't notice any issues so this may never be a problem.
I'm into this for about $125 and had enough parts for two kits (but only one $25 filter).