P1000 Is OIL COLOR related to burnt clutches?

Delton

Delton

Honda Fanboy
Vendor
Lifetime Member
Club Contributor
Jan 6, 2016
9,967
31,488
113
Middle TN
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
Mine looked brand new at 100 miles. I hated to get rid of it. I was gonna save it and use as bar chain oil for my saw but I'm kinda anal bout my Stihls and only use their products for my saw and weed eater lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dale5740
DTAGG

DTAGG

Active Member
Sep 11, 2015
166
238
43
ST GEORGE UTAH/ACCORD LAKES SEVIER COUNTY UTAH
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
Mine is sill in the drain pan so I stirred it up and smeared some on a paper towel for comparison to the picture above.
@DTAGG - was your filter dark ?

View attachment 11471
i only changed filter at 100 miles both of which were dark . I didn't notice any metal flakes in filter and for the most part the oil was pretty clean when i changed it at 100. I have 450 miles on current oil and the pic is from checking oil on both dipsticks engine and trans last night as this subject came up. I noticed i was a little low on oil in engine by a few ounces so i topped it off. looking at the clean oil and the way my machine runs, i will be riding happy for a while. of course checking often .
 
  • Like
Reactions: ghost and dale5740
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
who has the most miles when clutch problems started ( we have see n early clutch problems what about late ones) I want to know as I'm sure everyone else does as well that if I don't have a problem by a certain point then I wont at all. Anyone with burnt clutches after a couple hundred miles?
 
Bayouownbeer

Bayouownbeer

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Jun 3, 2014
797
1,120
93
Chauvin LA
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
You're talking engine oil - not sub trans right?
Not good :(
This is how mine looked at 92 miles. Does not smell burnt. I've been relatively gentle with the machine too. No gnarly stuff.

View attachment 11470
Changed my oil yesterday at exactly 100 miles it was about same color as this. I've changed a lot of oil in vechicles and I'd say it looked about right for a breaking oil at 100 miles. It wasn't bunt smelling or black on a rag but it was dark. And I still cannot get my clutches to slip again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jshell3 and ghost
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
Changed my oil yesterday at exactly 100 miles it was about same color as this. I've changed a lot of oil in vechicles and I'd say it looked about right for a breaking oil at 100 miles. It wasn't bunt smelling or black on a rag but it was dark. And I still cannot get my clutches to slip again.
I'm worried for you sounds not good!! We will see ( if u rode real real hard I could see oil being a little dark maybe but from what we have heard from other riders who do ride hard it should look like new) keep an eye out! Also a lot of room for error here because as u all know when u put oil in a napkin it always looks cleaner than in a pail or bowl of some sort keep the pic rolling
 
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
Mine looked brand new at 100 miles. I hated to get rid of it. I was gonna save it and use as bar chain oil for my saw but I'm kinda anal bout my Stihls and only use their products for my saw and weed eater lol.
Would u say u ride hard medium????
 
Delton

Delton

Honda Fanboy
Vendor
Lifetime Member
Club Contributor
Jan 6, 2016
9,967
31,488
113
Middle TN
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
Would u say u ride hard medium????
I would say I ride between medium and hard. Always after deep mud or big rocks to climb. I don't use alot of rpms, I make motor work for a living lol.
 
Bayouownbeer

Bayouownbeer

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Jun 3, 2014
797
1,120
93
Chauvin LA
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
Changed my oil yesterday at exactly 100 miles it was about same color as this. I've changed a lot of oil in vechicles and I'd say it looked about right for a breaking oil at 100 miles. It wasn't bunt smelling or black on a rag but it was dark. And I still cannot get my clutches to slip again.
I did have a decient amount of metal in the engine filter haven't opened the DTC yet.
ImageImage Image
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hondasxs

Hondasxs

Club Founder
Staff member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 13, 2013
18,500
67,170
113
Charlotte, NC
HondaSxS.com
Ownership

  1. 1000-5

  2. Talon R
Thanks @Bayouownbeer, Thats what I wanted to see.
Tho I see some in your filter. It is not as much as we found in the 700's.
And thats a good sign.
 
advertisement
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
metal is ok. what u don't want to see is gold specs thats bad!!! gold is from bearings
 
Hometeam

Hometeam

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Nov 26, 2015
995
4,154
93
Normal, IL
@dale5740 I am a little confused here....I didn't see this thread you had started in this section when I posted my post in the clutches slipping thread....and this is what I was basically getting at with that post (maybe I didn't do a good job stating it:)). But conventional oil that has taken contamination from clutchs heat or wear and breakin metals and lubes ( I know that there is not enough lube in assembly to do this by itself but was just stating that it adds to the overall breakdown) used will have lost a lot of it's lubricity properties and could effect a number of things especially when it sounds like the shifting uses oil pressure and the clutchs get the oil. That's why I said that full synthetic, which doesn't break down at the same rate and stands up to heat abuse better( like being buried in mud and straining the motor and trans more and heat building up), might help battle some of the clutch issues/questions. I detailed my breakin process because my machine never saw oil that had be darkened by heat, metal, or anything else in the breakin process and runs flawless. Also I bought my P1000 a week before thanksgiving so it was definitely an earlier one. Are we kind of brain storming the same thought here??) Since post can not show personal expression I want to be clear that I am not meaning anything negative here. Just open discussion!!;)
 
ghost

ghost

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Dec 4, 2015
993
1,873
93
BC
I changed my oil earlier this week (break in service) and man, it runs smooth now.
Shifting is much quieter and less clunky.

I took it for a test drive after the engine oil change but before I did the sub-trans. I thought I noticed a bit of slippage while changing gears - barely noticeable - not as nearly bad as some videos on the other thread. No other changes at that point.

Then I changed the sub-trans oil and my last couple rides have been excellent - like I said above with smooth quiet shifting. That does not make sense to me - unless it just took a couple of rides for the machine to respond to the new engine oil. Maybe someone else can explain it.
 
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
@dale5740 I am a little confused here....I didn't see this thread you had started in this section when I posted my post in the clutches slipping thread....and this is what I was basically getting at with that post (maybe I didn't do a good job stating it:)). But conventional oil that has taken contamination from clutchs heat or wear and breakin metals and lubes ( I know that there is not enough lube in assembly to do this by itself but was just stating that it adds to the overall breakdown) used will have lost a lot of it's lubricity properties and could effect a number of things especially when it sounds like the shifting uses oil pressure and the clutchs get the oil. That's why I said that full synthetic, which doesn't break down at the same rate and stands up to heat abuse better( like being buried in mud and straining the motor and trans more and heat building up), might help battle some of the clutch issues/questions. I detailed my breakin process because my machine never saw oil that had be darkened by heat, metal, or anything else in the breakin process and runs flawless. Also I bought my P1000 a week before thanksgiving so it was definitely an earlier one. Are we kind of brain storming the same thought here??) Since post can not show personal expression I want to be clear that I am not meaning anything negative here. Just open discussion!!;)
nothing negative taken!!! at all!! I definitely encourage any and all thoughts and comments on this subject as we pick apart different thoughts and ideas we ALWAYS learn from it we are def on the same page. Thanks for your input..!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hometeam
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
I changed my oil earlier this week (break in service) and man, it runs smooth now.
Shifting is much quieter and less clunky.

I took it for a test drive after the engine oil change but before I did the sub-trans. I thought I noticed a bit of slippage while changing gears - barely noticeable - not as nearly bad as some videos on the other thread. No other changes at that point.

Then I changed the sub-trans oil and my last couple rides have been excellent - like I said above with smooth quiet shifting. That does not make sense to me - unless it just took a couple of rides for the machine to respond to the new engine oil. Maybe someone else can explain it.
did u go with conventional or synthetic?
 
ghost

ghost

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Dec 4, 2015
993
1,873
93
BC
Conventional in the engine - GN4
Synthetic in the sub-trans.
 
dale5740

dale5740

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Supporting Member
Feb 4, 2016
886
417
63
mt airy md
Conventional in the engine - GN4
Synthetic in the sub-trans.
what is your thought behind that? do u plan to go to synthetic in the engine next oil change?
 
ghost

ghost

Well-Known Member
Lifetime Member
Dec 4, 2015
993
1,873
93
BC
That's what I'm thinking but I want to spend some more time with the Honda oil in the engine/dct for breakin. Maybe at 300 miles I'll switch. The sub trans oil will be in there longer so wanted to go synthetic now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dale5740
ButchersHook

ButchersHook

Well-Known Member
May 13, 2015
167
332
63
Wisconsin
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
That's what I'm thinking but I want to spend some more time with the Honda oil in the engine/dct for breakin. Maybe at 300 miles I'll switch. The sub trans oil will be in there longer so wanted to go synthetic now.

You are aware that Honda makes a full synthetic oil??

I just found it odd you want more time with Honda oil then switch to synthetic?
 
advertisement

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

User Menu

Buy us a beer!

  • Lots of time and money has gone into making sure the community is running the best software, best designs, and all the other bells and whistles. Care to buy us a beer? We'd really appreciate it!

    Beer Fund!

    Club Membership!