Firearm of choice for deer season?

SouthwestORV

SouthwestORV

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2018
744
1,730
93
Taylor, Arizona
Ownership

  1. 500
What caliber, model rifle does everybody use for hunting deer. I prefer my old trusty Remington 700 bdl in 270 with 150 grain core lokts
For elk I use my Tikka T3 in 243. Federal Blue Box 100gr soft points. Puts meat on the table no problem.

80ECC85C B92B 45A0 BFB5 9C3F2F354EF3
 
rtn001

rtn001

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2018
317
945
93
Central Florida
Ownership

  1. 500
For now my go to is a Savage mod. 11 lightweight in 6.5 creedmoor. 3x9 40mm Leupold. Hornady 129 gr. SST's. 3/4 inch group at one hundred yards. A little over 6 inch drop at 300 yards with a 1 and 3/4 inch group.
My second go to is a Winchester high wall in 7mm WSM. 4X12 40mm Leupold. Winchester factory 150 gr. ammo. Under a inch at 100 yards if I do my job.
For black powder my go to is a custom build Southern Va. (Cir. 1775 - 1785) flintlock rifle built by Wick Ellerbe in 54 Cal. Shooting a .530 patched round ball.
 
Cal

Cal

Active Member
Apr 15, 2018
70
122
33
Minnesota
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
I used my trusty Remington 870 express for 25+ years here in Iowa. Recently purchased land in Wisconsin and wanted a gun I could use in both. Just picked up a Ruger American .350 Legend. Love the gun and ammo is affordable. Since it’s a straight walled cartridge, I can use it in Iowa too.
I wish Minnesota would do that too! Where I'm at in MN it can only be shotgun, muzzleloader, or pistol. I use a 20ga 870 Express with a smoothbore slug barrel and iron sights that I've had since I was a kid. A few years back I bought a CVA Wolf (I know they're cheap, but I didn't know how much I'd actually go out when it's that effing cold). Last year a added a Vortex Diamondback 2 to 7 to the Wolf and it's actually pretty damn accurate so I mostly used it for longer range areas during slug season.

I used to my Beretta 96FS INOX or my Ruger Vaquero 44Mag, but I got superstitious as I would ONLY EVER see fawns and spikes when hunting with those! Four years in a row! Switched back to by shotgun muzzleloader combo and shoot a 9 pionter the first year. Three years ago I traded the Vaquero for an H&K VP9 and it was a great decision! I even got into some casual USPSA competition shooting with it. Fun pistol!

I have a Ruger Gunsite Scout .308 and a M+M M10 (or AKM) that I used when I used to go out to Wyoming, but my job hasn't allowed that to happen for years. ...It looks like I need to get my priorities straight...
 
Last edited:
Lilred500

Lilred500

Keep it on the rubber side
Supporting Member
Jul 9, 2019
548
1,997
93
Wv
Ownership

  1. 500
It depends on my mood but currently my top choice is a Remington 783 in 6.5 Creedmoor burping out 130 grain Sierra game changers of my own recipe. I'm also very fond of 7mm-08 Rem and 308 Win.
Have my grandpas old savage 110 in 7mm-08 little booger kicks like a mule but it’s priceless and will be passed on someday.
 
Lilred500

Lilred500

Keep it on the rubber side
Supporting Member
Jul 9, 2019
548
1,997
93
Wv
Ownership

  1. 500
Depends on terrain and foliage, I like my 1895 Guide in 45-70 Govt., also my Ruger American in .308, and when I go gillie and smelly my .500 S&W Mag. works up close and personal, for open country long shots I like my M77 in .270 Winchester
Love my guide gun! Kicks like hell but defiantly kicks even harder on the other end!!!
 
Lilred500

Lilred500

Keep it on the rubber side
Supporting Member
Jul 9, 2019
548
1,997
93
Wv
Ownership

  1. 500
For now my go to is a Savage mod. 11 lightweight in 6.5 creedmoor. 3x9 40mm Leupold. Hornady 129 gr. SST's. 3/4 inch group at one hundred yards. A little over 6 inch drop at 300 yards with a 1 and 3/4 inch group.
My second go to is a Winchester high wall in 7mm WSM. 4X12 40mm Leupold. Winchester factory 150 gr. ammo. Under a inch at 100 yards if I do my job.
For black powder my go to is a custom build Southern Va. (Cir. 1775 - 1785) flintlock rifle built by Wick Ellerbe in 54 Cal. Shooting a .530 patched round ball.
I’ve been wanting to get a 6.5 haven’t been around one much but what I’ve hears it’s an awesome little round!
 
Vikes79

Vikes79

SKOL!
Lifetime Member
Jul 18, 2018
10,759
104,390
113
South Dakota
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
Maybe I’m ignorant but from how I’ve seen deer hunted in Iowa it’s got to be the most dangerous way of hunting deer I’ve ever seen.

What I observed was deer being hunted in a similar fashion that pheasants would be hunted in a corn row with blockers and walkers. Last I checked, deer don’t fly...so all shots are taken shoulder height and lower vs above.

Never seen so much lead flying in close quarters before.

I don’t see how a slug would be safer than a rifle.
 
I

Imacdon2

New Member
Nov 10, 2018
2
9
3
Balderson, Ontario, Canada
Ownership

  1. 1000-3
Did you get him this year.
Hello fellow Nova Scotian.
Where do you hunt.
I do mine in Cape Breton.
:)
Caper
OK I admit I'm from Nova Scotia. Got that guy last Saturday. Three bucks altogether.
Choosing a gun is a lot like choosing a s/s. You pick what your comfortable with. Friends/associates/family have a huge influence.
First honda was a 1972 CB 350. Look that up.
GetAttachmentThumbnail
 
MontanaBighorn

MontanaBighorn

Active Member
May 9, 2016
121
214
43
Billings, MT
CarryGuide.com
.30-06 has always been my favorite, but I also love .308, .270 and even .243 that is a perfectly ethical kill. Back east I've used .30-30 and .44 Magnum lever guns, but out west you can't get within that range usually. Today all I hear about is the 6.5, but I was killing deer 40 years ago with a .30-30 and seemed to manage just fine.
 
ohanacreek

ohanacreek

My EcoBoost has I4WD
Moderator
Lifetime Member
Jul 25, 2013
11,346
32,043
113
Shelby County, Alabama
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
.30-06 has always been my favorite, but I also love .308, .270 and even .243 that is a perfectly ethical kill. Back east I've used .30-30 and .44 Magnum lever guns, but out west you can't get within that range usually. Today all I hear about is the 6.5, but I was killing deer 40 years ago with a .30-30 and seemed to manage just fine.

Ive heard complaints of lost deer because they will still be able to stumble off after a 6.5CM unless you use the single blunt nose Hornady round.

These complaints are coming from guys who I KNOW don’t miss and have had no issues out of their 30-06,270,243 guns.

To me the CM is a long range target and varmit caliber. Is it accurate YES VERY, is it great for large game? It will kill something if you put a hole in it, but I think there are much better rounds and calibers for large game.
 
Vikes79

Vikes79

SKOL!
Lifetime Member
Jul 18, 2018
10,759
104,390
113
South Dakota
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
Ive heard complaints of lost deer because they will still be able to stumble off after a 6.5CM unless you use the single blunt nose Hornady round.

These complaints are coming from guys who I KNOW don’t miss and have had no issues out of their 30-06,270,243 guns.

To me the CM is a long range target and varmit caliber. Is it accurate YES VERY, is it great for large game? It will kill something if you put a hole in it, but I think there are much better rounds and calibers for large game.

I know people that use a .223 to hunt deer. In SD that’s the minimum caliber.

It takes a really well placed shot to bring them down without running off too.
 
ohanacreek

ohanacreek

My EcoBoost has I4WD
Moderator
Lifetime Member
Jul 25, 2013
11,346
32,043
113
Shelby County, Alabama
Ownership

  1. 1000-5
I know people that use a .223 to hunt deer. In SD that’s the minimum caliber.

It takes a really well placed shot to bring them down without running off too.
Yup a 22 will kill a deer, some rounds are just more efficient than others.

I'd rather have a quick clean takedown, no point in making the animal suffer. Also I am fat and out of shape so searching for one in the brush and thickets we have around here is not enjoyable. Im in it for the meat not the sport.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

User Menu

Buy us a beer!

  • Lots of time and money has gone into making sure the community is running the best software, best designs, and all the other bells and whistles. Care to buy us a beer? We'd really appreciate it!

    Beer Fund!

    Club Membership!